Exclusive Interview: Salem Star Seth Gabel



Published July 11, 2014

Seth Gabel photographed by Angelo KritikosPin
Seth Gabel photographed by Angelo Kritikos with styling by Wilford Lenov. Gabel wears button-down Calvin Klein, coat Jenny Schwarz, trousers Prada and belt American Apparel. Grooming by Andrea Pezzillo.

As the first season of WGN America’s hit show Salem draws to a close this week, we spoke to Seth Gabel about his role as the duplicitous Cotton Mather, his career as an actor thus far and his take on style and fashion.

The 32-year-old first came to the attention of audiences for his performance as Adrian Moore in Nip/Tuck, and more recently has gone on to impress in Fringe and Dirty Sexy Money amongst other work in film and on television. Now, with the hugely popular Salem already confirmed to be returning for a second season, the future looks very bright for Seth.

How would you describe your character Cotton Mather in Salem?

In Salem, Cotton Mather is depicted as a transcendentalist thinker born a hundred-and-something years too soon. He is at odds with the Puritan society around him and so too, with himself. Cotton Mather is an aristocrat, a scientist, a reverend and a ruthless witch hunter who battles not only the witches of Salem, but also the demons that lie deep within himself.

He must face his own crippling anxiety, repressed anger and sexual addiction and, ultimately, his Father.

Did you have to do anything special to prepare for the role? 

The process was mostly intuitive. I read many excerpts from the writings of the real Cotton Mather, including Magnalia Christi Americana, Pillars of Salt, and The Christian Philosopher to get a sense of his inner voice but the real wizardry began when I started having fittings with our brilliant costumer, Joseph Porro. The period specific wardrobe immediately transports you to another realm. The imposing boots my character wears fully informs his need to fulfill a role of intimidation and authority (this carries through the season until he finally takes his boots off and connects with his true, naturalist self).

Gabel wears button-down Topman.

What were your initial thoughts when you found out about the premise of Salem?

At first I thought Salem was just going to be another attempt to exploit tween-agers’ voracious appetite for supernatural romance, but I discovered so much more. On the surface, Salem has everything a potentially exploitative supernatural horror romance needs to be entertaining, but at its core is a real, emotional drama that transcends time and space. There’s something about those characters in that unique time period and circumstance that resonates today more than ever. We stand on the precipice of a new world and can make decisions that will lead us to darkness or to transcendence. We must learn from our past.

Is there anything about the story that shocked you?

This show is not afraid to push the limit. WGN America is a new network and the fear is that the executives will get gun shy about taking risks to offend people or put them out of their comfort zone. We’ve had nothing but support and they’ve actually encouraged us to push things further as long as it stays in the realm of what is truthful and relevant to the story.

What do you think of internet shows?

As Leo once said, “It’s the way of the future.” (The Aviator) It’s inevitable. I foresee a time when there is no difference between cable and internet and people will simply type in a web address to watch the shows they want. It’s already begun with Netflix, Amazon and HBO GO.

Do you think it’s going to be the new norm in the future?


You are known for playing characters that are anything but one note. Do you seek out these differences?

I have no patience for characters that are one dimensional. The world we live in is not black and white, it’s not even gray, it’s color. The characters I’m drawn to generally are existentialist thinkers struggling to know their place in a flawed and magnificent world.

Gabel wears button-down Topman and jacket G-Star Raw.

What actors do your admire or see as inspirations?

I learn something from every actor but Paul Newman, Humphrey Bogart, Jack Nicholson, Gary Oldman, Peter Sellers and Ellen Burstyn are some of the faves.

How would you describe your personal style?

I’ve only come to know it recently. I grew up in South Florida in the 80s and 90s so I was generally raised in the culture of an airport gift shop. After spending some time in New York, LA, and most recently New Orleans, I’d say my style is Optimistically Eccentric yet Classically Urbane. That is, if you catch me on a day where I’m not lazy.

Do you consider yourself someone who cares about fashion or are you a jeans and t-shirt type of guy? 

I do care about fashion but I don’t depend on using it as a form of expression to define me. Mostly my relationship to it is practical but I love any opportunity to make my day a little more interesting.

When you’re not working, what hobbies do you enjoy on your downtime? 

I love playing with my kids. As you age, the world can start to seem small and mundane. I remember as I kid I would dream about foreign countries and because I had never seen them, they were so incredibly exotic and mystical. When I’m with my kids, I see the world that way again and nothing can compare to that. I also like theoretical physics and my vinyl collection.

What’s next?

I’m developing a TV show and a comic book series and am absolutely dying to get back to work on season 2 of Salem!

Recent Updates

Exclusive: Stijn van Dongen in 'Wild Encounter'

Exclusive: Stijn van Dongen in ‘Wild Encounter’

In the wild splendor of Cornellskop animal sanctuary, Stijn van Dongen (New Generation Models) becomes one with natural beauty. Thomas ...
Exclusive: Presley Walker Stars in 'After the Afterparty'

Exclusive: Presley Walker Stars in ‘After the Afterparty’

In the afterglow of revelry, photographer Luyang Tian's lens captures Presley Walker (Photogenics), a figure of captivating juxtapositions, in "After ...
Wilhelmina Models LA Takes the Spotlight in Modern Denim

Wilhelmina Models LA Takes the Spotlight in Modern Denim

In the raw industrial confines of a Los Angeles loft, Wilhelmina LA models convene, embodying the rugged spirit of Americana ...
The Art of Detail: Kai Taylor Rocks Dolce & Gabbana

The Art of Detail: Kai Taylor Rocks Dolce & Gabbana

In a captivating fall-winter 2023 exclusive, photographer Dennis Weber collaborates with MGM model Kai Taylor to bring Dolce & Gabbana's Essenza collection into sharp focus. The ...
Tony wears bucket hat Zara x Rhuigi Villaseñor and vintage swim trunks Diesel.

Modern Nostalgia: Tony Rodriguez Sports Fresh Summer Style

Tony Rodriguez, a newcomer from Soul Artist Management, stars in our latest Fashionisto Exclusive. Staying true to the seasonal vibe, ...
Head in the Game: Victor Dons Hermès for New Exclusive

Head in the Game: Victor Dons Hermès for New Exclusive

Immersed in the world of Hermès, model Victor Donatz takes center stage in this Fashionisto Exclusive titled "Head in the ...